The Miami Dolphins added another notch to their successful 2024 campaign with a hard-fought 27-20 win over the New England Patriots. The game, held in the Dolphins’ home stadium, showcased Miami’s offensive prowess and defensive resilience. However, the victory also exposed significant flaws in the team’s execution, particularly with one key player, a former Pro Bowler whose performance has been underwhelming in recent weeks. Despite his credentials and past accolades, it might be time for the Dolphins to consider benching him to solidify their Super Bowl aspirations.
Analyzing the Victory
The Dolphins entered the game with an 8-2 record, looking to extend their lead in the AFC East. The Patriots, struggling with a 4-6 record, were hoping to spoil Miami’s momentum. Miami’s offense, led by Tua Tagovailoa, displayed its trademark explosiveness early, scoring two quick touchdowns in the first quarter. Tyreek Hill was once again a game-changer, racking up over 120 yards and a touchdown
On defense, the Dolphins managed to keep Patriots quarterback Mac Jones under pressure, forcing two critical turnovers. Linebacker Bradley Chubb and defensive end Jaelan Phillips spearheaded a relentless pass rush that stifled New England’s offensive rhythm.
But amidst the highlights, there was one glaring issue that stood out—a consistent underperformance by a key player, raising questions about his continued presence on the starting roster.
The Player in Question
Xavien Howard, a two-time Pro Bowler and former All-Pro cornerback, has been a cornerstone of Miami’s defense for years. Known for his ball-hawking skills and ability to lock down top receivers, Howard was instrumental in the Dolphins’ resurgence as an AFC powerhouse. However, this season has been far from his best.
Against the Patriots, Howard was repeatedly targeted by Mac Jones, who threw for over 150 yards against him. Howard was responsible for several blown coverages, including a 45-yard bomb to Demario Douglas and a crucial third-down conversion in the fourth quarter that allowed the Patriots to keep the game close. His inability to adapt to New England’s offensive schemes was apparent, leaving many wondering if his best days are behind him.
Declining Performance
Howard’s struggles are not new. Over the past six games, he has allowed an average of 75 yards per game to opposing receivers. Quarterbacks have a passer rating of 112.3 when targeting him, significantly higher than his career average. His tackling, once a strength, has also regressed, with several missed opportunities in key moments.
While injuries have plagued Howard in recent seasons, the Dolphins can no longer afford to make excuses for his play. His $18 million cap hit, one of the highest for a cornerback in the league, adds to the scrutiny. Miami’s front office and coaching staff face a tough decision: continue to hope for a turnaround or make a bold move to bench him in favor of younger, more consistent options.
Depth in the Secondary
One reason the Dolphins can entertain benching Howard is their depth at cornerback. The emergence of Kader Kohou, a second-year player out of Texas A&M-Commerce, has been a revelation. Kohou’s aggressive style and sound fundamentals have earned him praise from teammates and coaches alike. In the game against New England, Kohou recorded an interception and three pass breakups, effectively shutting down his side of the field.
Additionally, rookie Cam Smith has shown flashes of brilliance in limited snaps. The second-round pick possesses the speed and instincts to thrive in Miami’s defensive scheme. Giving Smith more opportunities could be a win-win situation, allowing him to develop while potentially improving the team’s overall performance.
The Coaching Perspective
Head coach Mike McDaniel has built his reputation on making difficult but necessary decisions. Known for his analytical approach, McDaniel prioritizes performance over pedigree. During the post-game press conference, McDaniel addressed Howard’s struggles, stating:
> “Xavien is a great player with a tremendous track record. That said, football is a performance-based business. We’re evaluating everyone, including myself, to ensure we’re putting the best product on the field.”
Defensive coordinator Vic Fangio echoed similar sentiments, emphasizing the need for accountability. Fangio’s scheme relies heavily on cornerbacks excelling in man coverage, a role Howard has struggled to fulfill consistently this season.
The Risks of Benching Howard
Benching a player of Howard’s stature is not without risks. It could create locker room tension or be perceived as a lack of loyalty to a veteran leader. Howard is a respected figure in Miami’s locker room, and his teammates often speak highly of his mentorship and football IQ.
Moreover, there’s always the chance that benching him could backfire. Younger players like Kohou and Smith may not be ready for an expanded role, leading to a decline in defensive efficiency. However, the Dolphins have reached a point where the potential rewards outweigh the risks.
The Bigger Picture
Miami’s aspirations extend beyond the regular season. With the Kansas City Chiefs, Baltimore Ravens, and Jacksonville Jaguars all vying for AFC supremacy, the Dolphins cannot afford any weak links. Howard’s struggles have made him a target for opposing quarterbacks, and playoff-caliber teams will exploit that vulnerability.
By making a proactive decision now, Miami can address the issue before it becomes a liability in the postseason. The team’s ultimate goal is to bring a Lombardi Trophy to South Florida, and tough choices are often necessary to achieve greatness.
What’s Next?
The Dolphins have a short week ahead as they prepare to face the New York Jets on Thanksgiving Day. The Jets’ passing attack, while inconsistent, features explosive playmakers like Garrett Wilson, who could pose a significant challenge.
If Howard starts and continues to underperform, it may force McDaniel’s hand. However, if the coaching staff decides to bench him, it will mark a turning point for the franchise. Regardless of the decision, the message is clear: the Dolphins are all-in on their championship quest, and sentimentality has no place in that pursuit.
Conclusion
The Miami Dolphins’ victory over the Patriots was a testament to their talent and resilience. However, it also highlighted a growing problem in their defense. Xavien Howard, once a cornerstone of the team, has become a liability. His declining performance, combined with the emergence of younger talent, makes a compelling case for a change.
As the Dolphins march toward the postseason, every decision matters. Benching Howard may be a controversial move, but it could also be the spark that propels Miami to Super Bowl glory. For now, all eyes are on Mike McDaniel and his staff as they navigate this critical juncture in the season.
Leave a Reply